Tuesday, September 12, 2006

The politics of celebrating death

An increasingly common way of pissing off Tories in Student Unions is to bring a motion promising to hold a party on the day Margaret Thatcher dies. Most commonly this is described as being in 'bad taste' or 'offensive' (in the abstract). Conversely I was struck when in America by the coverage of Floridans openly dancing in the streets at the news that Castro was dying. There was no condemnation, no unease, no sense whatsoever that this might be in bad taste. Indeed, it's notable that the most outraged at the suggestion one might celebrate Thatcher's death don't seem to have such a problem when it comes to Castro or Al-Zarqawi.

It does, however, throw up another question: Is there anything wrong with celebrating death?

One of the most common retorts in these comical Thatcher debates (the right takes them,and themselves, absurdly seriously) is something akin to "how would you feel if we held a party to celebrate Scargill's death?" Well, personally I'm not sure I'd be that fussed by Scargill dying, but I take the point, how would I feel if someone celebrated the death of someone I admired, respected and supported? Well, i'd be annoyed, sure. Someone glorying in Paul Foot's death would have been an extremely unpleasant thing for me to see. However, I'm not sure how significant that really is. I don't think I'd be offended because this was a tasteless offence to the dead (to some abstract group of people who've passed away whom I should venerate), but I think I'd be offended because it was an insult to someone who's values I share.

A celebration of Thatcher's death would sure as hell be offensive to Tories, but I'm not sure I'd be offended much. It would be offensive to Thatcher, in as much as she continued to exist, but if I had Thatcher right in front of my right now I imagine I'd be quite offensive to her. To me celebrating Castro's death seems unnecessary (though under certain circumstances the end of that regime would be no bad thing), but to those exiles it was an important statement.

It seems to me that this is exactly what celebrating a death is, it is communicating a statement, and in most cases a political one. I wouldn't want someone to celebrate Paul Foot's death for exactly the same reason I don't like it when Tories spout daft arguments, I'd disagree with the statement and the ideology behind it, not because it offended some grand principle of taste, dignity or respect.

30 Comments:

At 1:30 pm, Blogger Jacob Bard-Rosenberg said...

Good stuff! This whole respect for the dead thing is tied up with some dodgy Christian morality. I certainly don't respect Thatcher while she's alive, so I can't see why her immanent death will change that. In other news, I'm writing a motion for council I on the Israeli incursion into Lebanon - do you feel like seconding it? Maybe see you on Saturday too.

 
At 8:15 pm, Anonymous kylie said...

eh, youre judging the views of those who believe celebrating thatchers death is wrong on the actions of those who live thousands of miles away from them? how the fuck did you work that out?

residents of florida may not be dignified, but generally "tories in the student union" are and would rather keep their mouth shut.

 
At 11:27 pm, Blogger DanS said...

Actually, Kylie, I'm not judging anyone here by the actions of people in Florida, just comparing the two. It is, however, my experience that there's a bit of hypocrisy, and that tories do tend to not have a problem celebrating the death of people they don't like.

My main point, though, was simply that there is nothing wrong with celebrating death per se, in my opinion. This means that the tories are not necessarily hypocritical, but just plain wrong.

 
At 9:29 am, Anonymous kylie said...

hey dan,

you may have a point, but i don't recall any major leftwing figures dying during my lifetime to test uk tories opinion on. i know the sun LOVED the death of al-zarqawi but he's hardly a wholesome left-wing politician is he? more of the same for the belgrano, which pretty much celebrated mass murder, compared to outrage at saddam welcoming the downing of the twin towers, although there's obvious differences i guess.

just some general thought trails there

 
At 1:04 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I didnt find thing that i need... :-(
[url=http://yahoo.com]yahoo[/url]

 
At 7:59 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Bush and the Republicans were not protecting us on 9-11, and we aren't a lot safer now. We may be more afraid due to george bush, but are we safer? Being fearful does not necessarily make one safer. Fear can cause people to hide and cower. What do you think? What is he doing to us, and what is he doing to the world?
If ever there was ever a time in our nation's history that called for a change, this is it!
The more people that the government puts in jails, the safer we are told to think we are. The real terrorists are wherever they are, but they aren't living in a country with bars on the windows. We are.

 
At 9:49 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hello Everybody Out There !!! Very Many Thanks for kindly signing (and globally circulating) this New Downing Street Petition at http://petitions.pm.gov.uk/AbolishGMC

 
At 8:31 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Bonjour, oppositeofapathy.blogspot.com!
[url=http://cialischwa.pun.pl/ ]Achat cialis [/url] [url=http://viagratitu.pun.pl/ ]Acheter viagra [/url] [url=http://cialismaro.pun.pl/ ] cialis en ligne[/url] [url=http://viagraline.pun.pl/ ]Achat viagra online[/url] [url=http://cialistina.pun.pl/ ]Acheter du cialis online[/url] [url=http://viagradysi.pun.pl/ ]Acheter viagra [/url]

 
At 12:37 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi!!! oppositeofapathy.blogspot.com is one of the most excellent informational websites of its kind. I take advantage of reading it every day. I will be back.

 
At 5:01 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The author of oppositeofapathy.blogspot.com has written an excellent article. You have made your point and there is not much to argue about. It is like the following universal truth that you can not argue with: The less you know about something, the easier it is to hate it. Thanks for the info.

 
At 9:09 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

gay personals state college pa [url=http://loveepicentre.com/]dating direct kingston upon hull[/url] intimate encounter dating services http://loveepicentre.com/ speed dating in london

 
At 3:20 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

oppositeofapathy.blogspot.com is the best. Thank your for this article. I enjoyed it very much.
AAA Toronto Payday Loans 1172 Bay St #101, Toronto, ON M5S 2B4 (416) 477-2817

 
At 5:22 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

http://alwayshealth.in/smoking/free-no-smoking-printable-sign
[url=http://alwayshealth.in/oxcarbazepine/psychiatric-uses-of-oxcarbazepine]drug posession charge central florida[/url] play drug dealing games [url=http://alwayshealth.in/canada-pharmacy/suburban-home-health-center-and-pharmacy-in-west-hartford]suburban home health center and pharmacy in west hartford[/url]
generic drug names are written http://alwayshealth.in/medical-co/lincoln-medical-center-home-page-ny
[url=http://alwayshealth.in/people-health/northumberland-health-care]drug seisure auction cigarett boat[/url] drug rehab connecticutt [url=http://alwayshealth.in/pravastatin/chiral-centers-of-pravastatin]chiral centers of pravastatin[/url]
what is a clinical drug http://alwayshealth.in/stress/stress-and-working-for-the-department-of-transportation
[url=http://alwayshealth.in/oxcarbazepine/oxcarbazepine]jersey drug dealer[/url] walmart pharmacy bainbridge ga [url=http://alwayshealth.in/oxybutynin/oxybutynin-chloride-hyperhidrosis-dermitologist]oxybutynin chloride hyperhidrosis dermitologist[/url] antecubital rash from statin drugs [url=http://alwayshealth.in/article-syndrome/grey-garden-news-diogenes-syndrome]grey garden news diogenes syndrome[/url]

 
At 3:02 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

gardiner automobile manufacturer http://automotoportal.in/mercedes/mercedes-lander-swimsuit animated automobile electrical diagrams
[url=http://automotoportal.in/saleen/saleen-explorer]mercedes benz m class for sale[/url] how to maintain an automobile [url=http://automotoportal.in/lincoln/lincoln-of-modesto]lincoln of modesto[/url]
mercedes cotner http://automotoportal.in/motorcycle/bmw-motorcycle-service
[url=http://automotoportal.in/rally/toyo-rally-tires]future hr issues in the automobile industry[/url] grundy county racing sims [url=http://automotoportal.in/pontiac/door-hinge-for-pontiac-firebird]door hinge for pontiac firebird[/url]
dodge charger dash bezel http://automotoportal.in/lotus/lotus-heart-yoga-centre
[url=http://automotoportal.in/radiator/radiator-rotting]blank automobile sale contract[/url] wood dash kit for mercedes c220 [url=http://automotoportal.in/motor-com]motor com[/url]

 
At 12:32 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

wholesale maternity clothes http://topcitystyle.com/?action=products&save_s_prm=1&pr_sort_=price trendy maternity clothes [url=http://topcitystyle.com/-wallet-men-category78.html]mike v shoes[/url] ralph lauren walnut
http://topcitystyle.com/light-purple-tops-shirts-with-colar-color202.html cruise clothes [url=http://topcitystyle.com/-leather-bags-tote-purses-category39.html]designer colthing[/url]

 
At 8:23 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

mercedes benz of anahiem http://carautonews.in/bike-com/titanium-mountian-bike-frames auto hide ie address bar
[url=http://carautonews.in/eagle/aguila-golden-eagle-centurian]mercedes motor homes[/url] tranferring automobile title financed [url=http://carautonews.in/chrysler/chrysler-hhr]chrysler hhr[/url]
how to san andreas grand theft auto http://carautonews.in/ducati/atlanta-ducati-triumph
[url=http://carautonews.in/aprilia/aprilia-2008]availability of 2008 dodge caliber in australia[/url] yamaha 660 grizzly 4x4 auto manul [url=http://carautonews.in/automobiles/global-positioning-units-for-automobiles]global positioning units for automobiles[/url]
review volkswagen eos hard top convertible http://carautonews.in/daihatsu/daihatsu-charade-review
[url=http://carautonews.in/bikes]vendita auto multimarche torino[/url] automobile designing [url=http://carautonews.in/automobile/ebay-automobile-auction]ebay automobile auction[/url]

 
At 9:35 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

sexy sarah from big naturals http://planetofporn.in/oral/braun-oral-b-ultra-plaque-remover-replacement-heads
[url=http://planetofporn.in/blowjob/blowjob-bimbows]ebony anal hoe black fuck hard[/url] adult children and their parents [url=http://planetofporn.in/ass-video/miss-big-ass-brazil-4]miss big ass brazil 4[/url]
i want to adopt an adult in australia http://planetofporn.in/adult-stories/adult-foruims
[url=http://planetofporn.in/ass-video/juicy-ass-and-chunky-thighs]free porn cartoon movies[/url] anal insertions to bowle [url=http://planetofporn.in/adult-stories/free-adult-strip-poker-games]free adult strip poker games[/url]
lesian double dildo http://planetofporn.in/adult-stories/free-adult-chat-motarated-java
[url=http://planetofporn.in/anal-life/white-anal-black-cock]coy adult site[/url] parejas hentai [url=http://planetofporn.in/teen-ass/skinny-youtube-slim-ass-shaking]skinny youtube slim ass shaking[/url]
adult passwords forums http://planetofporn.in/adult-stories/e90-adult-games-download
[url=http://planetofporn.in/hcg-oral/oral-presentation-evaluation-tool]virgin mobile wildcard and linux[/url] adult chat no sign in [url=http://planetofporn.in/oral/advantages-of-the-oral-system-of-communication]advantages of the oral system of communication[/url]

 
At 8:58 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

sexy loving wife http://theporncollection.in/best-porn/erotic-stories-free-porn
[url=http://theporncollection.in/gay-male/free-amateur-homemade-gay-porn]erotic adult vacations buenos aires[/url] anal fissures ayurveda [url=http://theporncollection.in/lesbian-xxx/kent-lesbian-dating]kent lesbian dating[/url]
adult sedation in diaper http://theporncollection.in/lesbian-porn
[url=http://theporncollection.in/hentai-sex/sonic-hentai-by-kio]dubai girl anal[/url] the boondocks hentai [url=http://theporncollection.in/gay-sex/robert-reynolds-gay]robert reynolds gay[/url]
teen dildo http://theporncollection.in/best-porn/romain-de-marchi-porn
[url=http://theporncollection.in/mature-woman/hairy-mature-lady-sonia]metal gear hentai solid[/url] yahoo messenger adult audibles [url=http://theporncollection.in/porn-dvd/cute-couples-porn]cute couples porn[/url]
amateur girls undressing http://theporncollection.in/gay-porn/gay-sex-a-blast-from-the-past-no-rubbers
[url=http://theporncollection.in/gay-man/gay-bosnian-men]alien love hentai[/url] adult gaiieries [url=http://theporncollection.in/hentai-porn/hentai-kiddy-grade]hentai kiddy grade[/url]

 
At 4:07 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

adult phone numbers in san diego http://xwe.in/toon/toon-models
[url=http://xwe.in/blow/daniel-blow]virgin atlantic san diego[/url] female virgin sex [url=http://xwe.in/adult-video/adult-education-classes-online]adult education classes online[/url]
massage porn movies http://xwe.in/archive-adult/adult-free-pornography
[url=http://xwe.in/girl-anal/anal-sex-dangers]anime underage porn[/url] sexy eating [url=http://xwe.in/shemales/wow-shemales]wow shemales[/url]
virgin sweetheart relax http://xwe.in/gay-boy/free-gay-video-glory-hole
[url=http://xwe.in/gay-anal/adam-levine-gay]sexy naked football cheerleaders[/url] radio amateur civil emergency services tarrant county [url=http://xwe.in/toon/tinkerbell-toon-porn]tinkerbell toon porn[/url]
reality porn site reviews http://xwe.in/hcg-oral/oral-sex-techniques-for-men
[url=http://xwe.in/gay-boy/chinese-boys-cute-gay-18]dildo personal size[/url] helda porn [url=http://xwe.in/ass-video/bbw-monster-ass]bbw monster ass[/url]

 
At 6:42 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

animated krishna movie on youtube [url=http://worldmovs.co.cc/full_version-det-okonda-/24356database/]Det Okonda [/url] gallatin tn movie theater [url=http://worldmovs.co.cc/full_version-abbott--costello-meet-the-mummy/12938database/]Abbott, Costello Meet The Mummy[/url]
movie soundtrack lyrics [url=http://full-length-movies.com/dvd-quality-movie-bill/25286database/]Bill[/url] mini videos for movie maker [url=http://worldmovs.co.cc/full_version-fem-myror---r-fler---n-fyra-elefanter-volym2/30218database/]Fem Myror ?„r Fler ?„n Fyra Elefanter Volym2[/url]
how to price horror movie collectibles [url=http://worldmovs.co.cc/full_version-national-treasure---book-of-secrets/4735database/]National Treasure - Book Of Secrets[/url] bourne movie [url=http://full-length-movies.com/dvd-quality-movie-the-sting/26703database/]The Sting[/url]
cast and crew of the movie school of rock [url=http://worldmovs.co.cc/full_version-faith-of-my-fathers/11556database/]Faith of My Fathers[/url] penis movie [url=http://worldmovs.co.cc/full_version-directos-al-infierno/24092database/]Directos Al Infierno[/url]

 
At 9:06 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

airport travel photos http://xwg.in/maps/gps-maps-europe calgary travel agents south america
[url=http://xwg.in]travel passaport information border[/url] chronological order of space travel [url=http://xwg.in/adventure/adventure-travel-tour-cheap-travel-insurance-http]adventure travel tour cheap travel insurance http[/url]
travel fitnessset http://xwg.in/airline/american-airline-arena
[url=http://xwg.in/tour/counterparts-tour-dates]time travel through dreams[/url] compare dicount travel [url=http://xwg.in/car-rental/denver-ski-package-car-rental]denver ski package car rental[/url]
travel options bend or http://xwg.in/flight/combat-flight-simulator-3-nuke-mod travel charger kit [url=http://xwg.in/expedia/poconos-lodging-expedia]poconos lodging expedia[/url]

 
At 12:00 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

laurence fishburne movies http://www.thefashionhouse.us/lilac-roberto-cavalli-color128.html fashion museums in milan [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/navy-blue-black-leather-shoes-color119.html]nurses shoes shop[/url] graphic designer job opportunities
http://www.thefashionhouse.us/sweaters-category24.html lauren crane nude [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/armani-jeans-pullover-for-men-navy-blue-item2250.html]gucci replica shoes[/url]

 
At 1:33 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

designer snow boots http://www.thefashionhouse.us/a-m-n-madness-national-tunic-brand55.html basketball shoes [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/m-polo-shirts-size5.html]graphic designer[/url] auth chanel coco cc logo charm necklace
http://www.thefashionhouse.us/abercrombie-and-fitch-t-shirts-for-men-brand63.html motorcycle clothes uk [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/navy-blue-white-color124.html]womens wide dress shoes[/url]

 
At 2:30 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

msypace fashion layouts http://luxefashion.us/44-sport-pants-size26.html hemp shoes [url=http://luxefashion.us/girls-new-category52.html]tap dancing shoes[/url] ralph lauren boys carpenter jeans
http://luxefashion.us/sweater-page2.html alternative clothes [url=http://luxefashion.us/sky-blue-casual-shirts-color96.html]sheila fashion designer[/url]

 
At 6:57 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

albert einstein college of medicine restaurants [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/synthroid.htm]synthroid[/url] best body part for vitamin b12 shots http://usadrugstoretoday.com/categories/miglioramento-femminile.htm
white dog health [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/anafranil.htm]anafranil[/url] drug tests and certo [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/categories/anti-saure.htm ]medical faculty associates washington dc [/url] muscle cars for salw
sleeping bags for kids [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/shallaki.htm]shallaki[/url] health clubs ma http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/purinethol.htm
mineral guidelines mg 112 [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/index.php?lng=uk&cv=po]No prescription online pharmacy[/url] medical id bracelet necklace [url=http://usadrugstoretoday.com/products/sarafem.htm ]health problems soft water [/url] prozac and diabetes

 
At 12:26 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

travel criggabe board http://xwl.in/hotel/copacabana-palace-hotel can silicone travel miles
[url=http://xwl.in/car-rental/alamo-rental-car-phone-number]travel cot usa[/url] travel trailer auctions [url=http://xwl.in/maps/ireland-rail-maps]ireland rail maps[/url]
travel clinic locations toronto http://xwl.in/hotel/hotel-neptuno-sicilia
[url=http://xwl.in/adventure/adventure-under-sail-torrent]joint federal travel[/url] christiansburg virginia local travel [url=http://xwl.in/cruises/cruises-around-europe]cruises around europe[/url]
travel tourism sacramento california ca http://xwl.in/tourism/daegu-tourism travel agent waterloo iowa [url=http://xwl.in/tourist/melburne-tourist-destinations]melburne tourist destinations[/url]

 
At 5:34 pm, Anonymous Anonymous said...

stylist fashion northwest indiana http://www.thefashionhouse.us/white-navy-blue-on-sale-color75.html who makeseditions clothes [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/juicy-couture-tracksuits-brand122.html]certified kitchen designers[/url] used maternity clothes
http://www.thefashionhouse.us/dolce-amp-gabbana-jeans-for-women-denim-blue-item1954.html infant girl clothes [url=http://www.thefashionhouse.us/men-casual-shirts-type1.html]insole shoes[/url]

 
At 3:12 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

gambling and national football league http://xwn.in/online-casinos gambling bonus blackjack strategies
[url=http://xwn.in/roulette_casino-black-jack-roulette]joker dark knight pic[/url] the lottery full text jackson [url=http://xwn.in/bingo_free-bingo-bonus-codes]free bingo bonus codes[/url]
max bet sportbook hard rock casino http://xwn.in/lottery_newcastle-united-lottery
[url=http://xwn.in/bingo_children-working-in-bingo-kitchen]imperial casino[/url] list of canadian casinos [url=http://xwn.in/casino-playing-cards_power-t-playing-cards]power t playing cards[/url]
gambling license macedonia http://xwn.in/online-casino_casino-cowlitz-county-non-profit-sites monte carlo resort casino [url=http://xwn.in/slots_alvin-and-the-chipmunks-time-slots]alvin and the chipmunks time slots[/url]

 
At 7:29 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

htl movie [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_the_player/]the player[/url] latin thugs song from the movie 10 items or less http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_dead_silence/ gallery magazine girl next door list movie dvd
perfume movie dvd [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_five_across_the_eyes/]five across the eyes[/url] free movie clips of paris hilton sex tape http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_omid_djalili_no_agenda_live_at_the_london_palladium/ movie song playlist
kingstowne movie theatre virginia show times [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_clueless/]clueless[/url] generic movie theme
a summery of the movie the miracle worker [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_the_unit/]the unit[/url] how to burn a movie http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_bill_ted_s_bogus_journey/ deceiver movie
initial d street stage movie [url=http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_scourge/]scourge[/url] brother air movie http://moviestrawberry.com/films/film_dane_cook_vicious_circle/ inukami the movie trailer

 
At 9:41 am, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hurrah, that's what I was looking for, what a stuff! existing here at this weblog, thanks admin of this site.
Also see my web page > rent apartments in santa monica

 

Post a Comment

<< Home